Yahoo has put up for auction over 3000 patents and expects to raise over US $1 Billion from it. Interestingly, this auction is separate from the core business of Yahoo for which Verizon and AT&T are likely to close on the biddings. That core business sales will have 500 granted patents and about 600 published patent applications included in it. However, the 3000 odd patents which are up for grabs is a separate transaction from that one.

In this report we will try to cover key technology areas of the portfolio, how strong is the future scope of the portfolio, and who are the most likely bidders for that portfolio. We will study the overall technology landscape from a patent filing perspective. We have identified that maximum patents are focused on search engines, ranking of the search results, advertisements and promotions, merging of the results, clustering and grouping of the results and relevance sorting of the results.

According to one NY post[1] article, the CFO of Yahoo Mr. Ken Goldman believes that their patents assets are worth 3-4 Billion dollars. However, our analysts believe that this valuation is unrealistic. Part of this valuation is likely due to the fact that Nortel in 2011 was able to sell its portfolio for a whopping US$ 4.5 Billion. However, because of Supreme Court’s landmark judgment in the case Alice Corp. v. CLS Bank International, the software patent’s enforcement has been affected drastically. This change in the patent litigation hemisphere makes it a lot easier for the defendants to rest their case against abstract computer patents. Hence, we believe that the portfolio is likely to be fetched at a much lower cost than this figure.

Using our proprietary in-house technology clustering algorithms, we have identified that Microsoft and Google are the highly likely frontrunners for bidding. We also expect that Millenial Media might also be interested in the patent portfolio related to advertising patents.

The following sections will contain Citius Minds’ detailed analysis on the Yahoo portfolio.

Key Technologies in the portfolio

Yahoo-TextCluster

Yahoo’s portfolio that is up for grabs has been recently assigned to Excalibur – a subsidiary of Yahoo specifically focused towards patent selling. The biggest advantage that the Yahoo portfolio has is its remaining patent life with an average remaining life close to 11 years 3 months if considered for granted patents only. However, if we take into consideration published applications that are not yet granted, that number goes up to 12 years 6 months. Clearly a very young portfolio and of immense future scope potential.

Using our in-depth analytic skills, we have identified few of the important sub-technologies on which Yahoo patents are focused. They have been represented in the below technology map. The size of the box indicates percentage of the number of patents filed in this domain, which nothing but indicates the relative importance of the technology sub-domain.

Yahoo-Blockcluster

Portfolio Life

The biggest advantage that Yahoo has going into this as it invites bids is the number of years left of their active patent portfolio. This portfolio’s average remaining life comes out to be 11 years and 3 Months. What even further turns the odds in their favor is the fact that they also have close to 45% of the portfolio which is not yet granted and which once granted will increase the average portfolio remaining life to 12 years and 6 Months. In fact, only 3.7% of the portfolio has a life span of less than 5 years left.

Yahoo-Life

The most likely bidders

Having a look at the portfolio in detail and also considering immense future scope of the patents, it is likely to be an intensive bidding war. From the looks of it, it seems that Microsoft and Alphabet are going to be the most likely bidders considering their popular search engines Bing and Google at the core of their service offerings and since the heart of this portfolio lies in the fact that the patents are focused on search engines, ranking results etc. Another competitors that are likely to show interest is IBM, Sales Force and Milennial Media. Milennial Media is a subsidiary of Verizon and it will make a lot of sense if they show keen interest on this portfolio as they are likely to close their bid on Yahoo’s core businesses. Less likely contenders are Facebook, Apple and Amazon because of these companies focus in revenues through advertisements, focus on AI in recent patents and also the internet of things.

Yahoo-TopBidders

The graph above reflects the number of patents and published applications of Yahoo, these company cites to which leads us to believe that their focus aligns pretty nicely with Yahoo’s portfolio which is up for sale. Interestingly, the last likely bidder in the list is Searete – a subsidiary of a patent trolling firm Intellectual Ventures. Considering their reputation of being a strong Non-practicing entity, it is likely to give Microsoft, Alphabet, IBM and Verizon a strong run for their money.

We will closely track this sale and share regular updates on how this bid is panning out.

[1] http://nypost.com/2016/04/07/yahoo-could-be-sitting-on-a-4b-patent-goldmine/

Website Comments

  1. Teresa
    Reply

    Hi, my name is Teresa and I just wanted to send you a quick note here instead of calling you. This is a really nice analysis. Thank you so much.

  2. Kelly
    Reply

    Yahoo is so smart. They know they have been run down by the big fishes already, it is much better of selling whatever they have, stick to their core and either get acquired in the future or be leaders in a niche.

    • Kailin
      Reply

      Knowledge wants to be free, just like these articles! Top quality stuff.

  3. Lynda
    Reply

    Very nice info. I think Intellectual Ventures will finally emerge as the grabbers.

  4. Hinshaw
    Reply

    The idea of predicting the most likely bidders according to the cited patents is so cool. I love the analysis. Thank you so much.

  5. Aleana
    Reply

    Everything depends on the technology and the remaining life of the patents. This article hits the nail on the head as it covers exactly the sweet spot of this auction.

  6. Matt
    Reply

    I have always used Yahoo mail as my mail client. I don’t agree with this decision.

Post a comment